MIAMI, OKLAHOMA — David Carlson, 50, of Whitesboro, Texas, has entered a blind plea in Ottawa County District Court to first-degree manslaughter and assault and battery with a dangerous weapon in the August 2025 crash that killed Oklahoma Turnpike Authority worker Zachary Rinehart. A blind plea is a guilty plea made without an agreement with prosecutors. Sentencing is set for February 2.

The Crash
Court records show Rinehart, 36, of Vinita, was stopped on the side of the Will Rogers Turnpike on August 18, 2025, outside his truck picking up trash and debris. Carlson’s semi, heading east on I-44, left its lane, struck the back of Rinehart’s work truck, and pushed it into Rinehart. Rinehart was killed, and another Turnpike Authority employee was injured.

What Investigators Found
Carlson first told investigators he had dropped his phone and crashed while trying to retrieve it. He later admitted he was watching anime, saying he used it as background noise to “keep from zoning out.” The Oklahoma Highway Patrol reviewed dash camera video from several sources and concluded Carlson was watching a television show and was distracted at the time of the crash.

Remembering Rinehart
Rinehart was a volunteer firefighter with the Vinita Fire Department and a member of the Craig County Technical Rescue Task Force. After his death, he received a hero’s escort home from Tulsa to Vinita, where the public lined South Wilson Street near Burckhalter-Highsmith Funeral Home. The Vinita Fire Department set up a GoFundMe to support his family and said it wanted to show the Rinehart family that the city stands with them.
All defendants are presumed innocent until sentenced in a court of law.
📸 Image(s) used under fair use for news reporting.

